A Department of Homeland Security Emeritus Center of Excellence led by the University of Maryland

A consortium of researchers dedicated to improving the understanding of the human causes and consequences of terrorism

The Frontiers of Uncertainty Estimation in Interdisciplinary Disaster Research and Practice


The Frontiers of Uncertainty Estimation in Interdisciplinary Disaster Research and Practice

Abstract: 

Conceptualizing, assessing, and managing disaster risks involve collecting and synthesizing pluralistic information—from natural, built, and human systems—to characterize disaster impacts and guide policy on effective resilience investments. Disaster research and practice, therefore, are highly complex and inherently interdisciplinary endeavors. Characterizing the uncertainties involved in interdisciplinary disaster research is imperative, since misrepresenting uncertainty can lead to myopic decisions and suboptimal societal outcomes. Efficacious disaster mitigation should, therefore, explicitly address the uncertainties associated with all stages of hazard modeling, preparation, and response. However, uncertainty assessment and communication in the context of interdisciplinary disaster research remain understudied. In this “Perspective” article, we argue that in harnessing interdisciplinary methods and diverse data types in disaster research, careful deliberations on assessing Type III and Type IV errors are imperative. Additionally, we discuss the pathologies in frequentist approaches, calling for an increasing role for Bayesian methods in uncertainty estimations. Moreover, we discuss the potential tradeoffs associated with information and uncertainty, calling for deliberate consideration of the role of diversity of information prior to setting the scope in interdisciplinary modeling. Future research guided by further reflections on the ideas raised in this article could help push the frontiers of uncertainty estimation in interdisciplinary hazard research and practice.

Publication Information

Full Citation: 

Nateghi, Roshanak, Jeannette Sutton, and Pamela Murray-Tuite. 2019. "The Frontiers of Uncertainty Estimation in Interdisciplinary Disaster Research and Practice." Risk Analysis (May). https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/risa.13337

START Author(s): 
Jeannette Sutton
Publication URL: 
Visit Website